Two different jobs that get called the same thing
People call us and say they want the land cleared. Nine times out of ten they mean one of two very different things. Forestry mulching is a track loader with a drum head that chews standing brush and small trees into chips and leaves them on the ground. Traditional clearing is pushing everything over with a dozer or excavator, piling it, then burning or hauling it off, and usually grubbing the stumps so you end up with bare dirt.
Both are legitimate. We run both. The right one depends on what you're doing with the ground afterward, how big the trees are, how wet the site is, and how much you want to spend. We'll walk through each of those so you can call us already knowing what to ask for — or at least knowing the right questions.
How forestry mulching actually works
Our mulching setup is a high-flow compact track loader with a forestry drum on the front. The teeth spin at a few thousand RPM and we feed trees into it top-down, taking them to the ground and then running over the stump until it's a few inches tall or flush. The result is a layer of wood chips two to six inches deep, depending on how thick the growth was.
The machine stays on tracks the whole time, so ground pressure is low. On Cecil and Appling red clay that matters, because once you rut clay with a wheeled machine or a heavy dozer in wet weather, you've created a drainage problem that will outlast your project. Mulching leaves the root mat in place, which holds the soil through the next storm.
The practical ceiling for mulching is tree size. Up to about eight inches at the stump, a mulcher is fast and clean. Eight to twelve inches, it still works but slows way down. Over that, we usually fell the tree, saw the trunk into logs you can keep or we can haul, and mulch the top and the stump.
How traditional clearing works
Traditional clearing means removing the vegetation entirely. We push or pull trees with the grapple or an excavator, pile them, and either burn the pile under a NC Forest Service burn permit or load it on the dump trailer. Then we grub — dig the stumps and root balls out with a stump bucket or root rake — and rough grade so you've got open, workable dirt.
This is the only approach when you need the ground gone: a house pad, a septic drain field, a pond, a road bed. You can't compact a building pad on top of a root mat and a bed of mulch. Site plans and engineers expect clean subgrade, and for good reason.
The downside is that you've just stripped the ground bare. In this part of North Carolina, bare red clay sheets water and erodes fast. If you disturb more than one acre, the NC Sedimentation Pollution Control Act requires an approved erosion and sedimentation control plan before the first bucket moves, and even under an acre you'll want silt fence and seed on anything you aren't building on soon.
Cost: why mulching is usually cheaper up front
Mulching is one machine, one operator, one pass. There's no hauling, no burning, no stump pile sitting in your field for six months. On light to medium brush we can cover an acre or more in a day. That makes it the cheapest way to open up ground — commonly a few hundred to a couple thousand dollars an acre depending on density and tree size.
Traditional clearing stacks costs: felling, piling, burning or hauling, grubbing, rough grading, and then erosion control. On a wooded acre with mature loblolly and hardwood, you're looking at several multiples of what mulching the same acre would run. It also takes longer, and if the weather turns, a grubbed site is a mud hole until it dries.
What tips the math the other way is purpose. If you mulch a lot you intend to build on, you'll end up paying to grub it later anyway. Mulch first only when you're clearing for visibility, pasture, trails, fence lines, or to see what you've got before you commit to a site plan.
What each one leaves behind on your land
After mulching: a mat of chips that breaks down over two to three growing seasons, stumps cut low that rot over a few years, and a surface you can mow with a rough-cut or bush hog once the chips settle. Hardwood stumps — sweetgum especially — will resprout, so plan on a follow-up mow or a cut-stump herbicide treatment if you want it to stay open.
After traditional clearing: bare, loose soil that needs grading and seeding, and a burn scar or a haul-off bill. No stumps, no resprouting, no chips. You can immediately disk it, plant it, pour on it, or compact a pad. If there was any grading to do, it's now easy.
There's a middle path we do a lot: mulch the small stuff, fell and haul the big trees, pull only the stumps that are in the way of a pad, driveway or septic field, and leave the rest. That gets you most of the cost savings of mulching with a buildable footprint where you need it.
Soil, water and the stuff the brochure skips
Piedmont clay infiltrates slowly. When you strip vegetation off it, rainfall runs instead of soaks. If your lot sits uphill from a creek in the Jordan Lake, Randleman Lake or Falls Lake watersheds, there are riparian buffer rules that limit what you can clear within fifty feet of the stream. Mulching is often allowed in the outer buffer zone where grubbing is not, because the roots stay.
Mulch also feeds the soil as it breaks down, but it ties up nitrogen for the first year. If you're mulching to make pasture, expect weak grass that first season unless you add nitrogen. If you're mulching a lot you want to look parked-out and neat, the chips settle into something that looks like a trail surface within a few months.
One more honest note: a mulched site in late summer can look rough for a few weeks. Chips are tan, stumps are visible, and resprouts show up. By the following spring it looks like a managed woodland. Traditional clearing looks worse immediately and better once it's graded and seeded — if it gets graded and seeded.
Which one we'd pick for common Triad jobs
Wooded lot you want to build on this year: traditional clearing of the pad, driveway and septic area; mulch the rest of the lot for privacy and to keep the tree canopy. Overgrown pasture with privet and sweetgum: mulch, then mow twice the next summer. Fence line or property line buried in brush: mulch, no question. Hunting tract that needs lanes and plots: mulch the lanes, grub and disk the plots.
Lot with twenty-inch oaks and poplars you want gone: fell and haul the logs, mulch the tops, mulch them to grade if you need a lawn or pull them if you need a pad. Land that floods or sits wet: mulch when it's dry and leave the roots alone, because a grubbed wet site turns into a pond you didn't ask for.
If you're still not sure, call us with the address and what you're planning. We'll look at it on the county GIS, drive out, and tell you straight which one makes sense. Most of the time the answer is some of both.
Related questions
Can I build a house on a lot that's been forestry mulched?
Not directly on the mulched surface. The pad, driveway and septic field still need to be grubbed and graded to clean subgrade. Mulching the rest of the lot is fine and saves money.
Does mulching kill the trees or will they grow back?
Pines and cedars die when cut. Hardwoods like sweetgum, maple and oak will resprout from the stump. A mow the next summer or a cut-stump herbicide keeps them down.
How big a tree can a forestry mulcher handle?
Our head is efficient up to roughly eight inches at the stump and workable to about twelve. Larger trees we fell with a saw, section the trunk, and mulch the top and stump.
Is a burn permit required to burn piles in North Carolina?
Yes, outside of city limits you need a burn permit from the NC Forest Service, available free online or at a permit agent. Inside city limits most municipalities prohibit open burning of land-clearing debris entirely.
About the author. Clark Sellars owns and operates A&R Land Services in Greensboro, NC. He's a veteran and a working firefighter, and he runs the mulcher, the track loader and the excavator on every job the company takes.